FCS (Division 1-AA) Football : Champions : Schools : Streaks : Series records : Most frequent matchups

 
  Colgate 1 - 0 against Boston University

  Games:
    (W)  1982  Colgate 21  -  Boston University 7     First Round



 
  Colgate 0 - 2 against Delaware

  Games:
    (L)  2003  Colgate 0   -  Delaware 40     Championship
    (L)  1982  Colgate 13  -  Delaware 20     Quarterfinals



 
  Colgate 1 - 0 against Florida Atlantic

  Games:
    (W)  2003  Colgate 36  -  Florida Atlantic 24     Semifinals



 
  Colgate 0 - 1 against Georgia Southern

  Games:
    (L)  1998  Colgate 28  -  Georgia Southern 49     First Round



 
  Colgate 0 - 1 against Illinois State

  Games:
    (L)  1999  Colgate 13  -  Illinois State 56     First Round



 
  Colgate 2 - 0 against James Madison

  Games:
    (W)  2018  Colgate 23  -  James Madison 20     Second Round
    (W)  2015  Colgate 44  -  James Madison 38     Second Round



 
  Colgate 1 - 0 against Massachusetts

  Games:
    (W)  2003  Colgate 19  -  Massachusetts 7     First Round



 
  Colgate 1 - 1 against New Hampshire

  Games:
    (W)  2015  Colgate 27  -  New Hampshire 20     First Round
    (L)  2005  Colgate 21  -  New Hampshire 55     First Round



 
  Colgate 0 - 1 against North Dakota State

  Games:
    (L)  2018  Colgate 0  -  North Dakota State 35     Quarterfinals



 
  Colgate 0 - 1 against Sam Houston State

  Games:
    (L)  2015  Colgate 21  -  Sam Houston State 48     Quarterfinals



 
  Colgate 0 - 2 against Villanova

  Games:
    (L)  2008  Colgate 28  -  Villanova 55     First Round
    (L)  1997  Colgate 28  -  Villanova 49     First Round



 
  Colgate 0 - 1 against Wagner

  Games:
    (L)  2012  Colgate 20  -  Wagner 31     First Round



 
  Colgate 0 - 1 against Western Carolina

  Games:
    (L)  1983  Colgate 23  -  Western Carolina 24     First Round



 
  Colgate 1 - 0 against Western Illinois

  Games:
    (W)  2003  Colgate 28  -  Western Illinois 27     Quarterfinals