Men's Division 1 Soccer : Champions : Schools : Streaks : Series records : Most frequent matchups

 
  Butler 1 - 0 against Cincinnati

  Games:
    (W)  1998  Butler 1  -  Cincinnati 0 (2OT)   First Round



 
  Butler 1 - 3 against Indiana

  Games:
    (L)  2009  Butler 0  -  Indiana 1         Second Round
    (L)  1998  Butler 1  -  Indiana 2 (2OT)   Second Round
    (L)  1997  Butler 1  -  Indiana 2 (3OT)   First Round
    (W)  1995  Butler 1  -  Indiana 0         First Round



 
  Butler 1 - 0 against Lipscomb

  Games:
    (W)  2017  Butler 2  -  Lipscomb 0     First Round



 
  Butler 0 - 2 against Michigan State

  Games:
    (L)  2010  Butler 0  -  Michigan State 1     Second Round
    (L)  2001  Butler 1  -  Michigan State 2     First Round



 
  Butler 0 - 1 against Portland

  Games:
    (L)  1995  Butler 1  -  Portland 4     Second Round



 
  Butler 0 - 1 against Southern Illinois-Edwardsville

  Games:
    (L)  2016  Butler 0  -  Southern Illinois-Edwardsville 0 (2OT:PK)   Second Round



 
  Butler 1 - 0 against Virginia Commonwealth

  Games:
    (W)  2017  Butler 3  -  Virginia Commonwealth 2     Second Round



 
  Butler 0 - 1 against Wake Forest

  Games:
    (L)  2017  Butler 0  -  Wake Forest 2     Third Round



 
  Butler 0 - 1 against West Virginia

  Games:
    (L)  2019  Butler 1  -  West Virginia 5     First Round